Why Feedback Alone Doesn’t Always Change Outcomes

Feedback conversations that don’t lead to change are one of the most frustrating experiences for leaders. You’ve delivered constructive feedback carefully and clearly. The team member seems to understand, but weeks pass, and nothing changes. Now you’re facing the same conversation again, confused about why your feedback hasn’t translated into the change you thought you had both agreed on.

What we know from research: Research examining how employees respond to feedback reveals a striking pattern. When leaders deliver constructive feedback alone, employees show moderate engagement with that feedback. But when the same feedback is delivered with a coaching approach, employee responses strengthen significantly.

Coaching produced stronger employee responses to feedback than just feedback alone (and this effect was significantly amplified for employees with a growth mindset).

My POV: Most leaders I work with know the importance of giving clear, direct feedback and actively work to upskill themselves in this. What’s tricky is that just sharing what needs to improve with someone rarely creates the conditions for actual change.

I see the following pattern repeatedly: leaders deliver feedback, the employee nods and accepts it, but significant behavioural change doesn’t follow or isn’t sustained. The difference lies in shifting from feedback as information delivery to feedback combined with a coaching style. This helps people know where they stand and be a part of co-creating their own path forward through challenges.

As a Leader, what can you do?

• Be a thought partner rather than an accidental judge. Give your feedback and be sure you understand their perspective of the situation and the challenges, before shifting into coaching conversations about how change will happen. This fundamentally changes how feedback lands.
• Co-create solutions rather than prescribe them. Ask thoughtful questions that help the person think differently, then build the path forward together. Try: “What do you think is getting in the way?” “If you could change one thing about your approach, what would have the biggest impact?” Once they’ve shared their thinking and you’ve shared yours, collaborate on the next steps: “What makes sense to try first? What might stop you from acting on this?”. When people generate insights alongside you rather than receiving directives from you, they’re far more committed to acting on them.
• Know that feedback alone rarely leads to change. Coaching conversations are redundant without the full context from feedback. Combine feedback and coaching conversations to drive meaningful change and avoid repeated conversations about the same issue.

What difference will it make? When you embed coaching into feedback conversations, team members are more likely to respond with genuine commitment. They’ll take the initiative with their development and persist through challenges because they believe growth is possible. For you as a leader, this means avoiding having to revisit the same difficult conversations again and leading a team that develops faster.

Never miss an insight. Receive our newest and unpublished leadership insights straight to your inbox every fortnight — sign up HERE